Home Home Home Home Home Home Home
CakeSpy

Featured: 

What is Pumpkin Pie Spice?

Unicorn Love: the Eating Disorder Recovery Blog

 

 Buy my brilliant books!

Buy my new book!

Buy my first book, too! 

CakeSpy Online Retail!

 

Archives
Gallery

Fantastic appliance for cake making on DHgate.com

everyrecipe.co.nz

Craftsy Writer
« Batter Chatter: Interview with Nancy Bea Miller, Painter of Baked Goods | Main | Cake Byte: Sweet News from Cakespy »
Sunday
Jun012008

Cupcakes Vs. Muffins: An Epic Battle and Some Big Questions

Faceoff time
Muffins versus cupcakes. It's a heavy--nearly epic--subject to tackle, but we've bravely wandered into this storm to better understand this mighty battle of the baked goods: who are they? How are they different? And ultimately, which is more lovable?

Cupcake, Magnolia Bakery, DowntownMuffin
Part 1: The Difference between Cupcakes and Muffins

First off--is there a difference between the cupped treats? There are certainly different schools of thought, as we found out:

According to our dictionary, a cupcake is defined as "a small cake, the size of an individual portion, baked in a cup-shaped mold," whereas the muffin is defined as "a small, cup-shaped quick bread, often sweetened." Strangely, the definitions don't touch on the subject of frosting, which to many seems to be a defining characteristic of a cupcake. However, they do touch on the subject of sweetness, citing that muffins are "often" sweetened, thus leaving it open to interpretation that they are often but not always sweet, and it does touch on their texture by defining them as a quick bread, which is often more dense than cake (think of the difference between say, a dense banana bread and the oft-lighter Hummingbird cake).

Or, as a commenter in an internet forum says, "If you threw a cupcake against the wall, you would hear something of a 'poof!' If you threw a muffin, you would hear a 'thud!'"

EATS Market CupcakesChocolate Cream Cheese Muffins, Metropolitan Market
While the above seems to lean toward differences in texture and sweetness, these days the line can be even further blurred with the addition of products such as carrot walnut muffins with a cream cheese glaze or black-bottom cream cheese and chocolate muffins (which kind of sound like cupcakes to us). To that point-- In a recent New York Times article, when one of our favorite food writers Melissa Clark asks a pastry chef friend what the difference is while devouring one of his particularly sweet and buttery muffins, his opinion on the difference between cupcakes and muffins is as follows:

'Nothing,' he said, explaining that when it comes to breakfast, Americans have a Puritanical inhibition. 'Muffins are just an excuse to eat cake for breakfast'

Vanilla Buttercream Cupcakes at Saint CupcakeMuch Ado about Muffin
And as a bit of curiosity: We also noticed that there's a difference between the words when used in slang. While both words are used as a term of affection (say, to refer to a child or loved one), "muffin" also has a negative connotation--the term "muffin top" rather indelicately refers to "the phenomenon of overhanging flesh when it spills over the waistline of trousers or skirt in a manner that resembles the top of a muffin spilling over its paper casing." Owch.

Cupcakes. And Muffins.
Part 2: We put it to the test

After having researched the above, we were left unsatisfied--so we decided to do a little experiment. What did we do? Well. We baked one batch of muffins, and one batch of cupcakes, with recipes found online--both for batches of 20 in a similar flavor, apple spice. They're both pictured above. Can you tell the difference?

Now, we realize that there are all sorts of recipes out there, so we're not saying this is going to be true in every case, but with our two recipes, the major differences were as follows:
  • Oven temperature and baking time: the cupcakes were baked at 350 for 30 minutes, and the muffins were baked at 375 for 25 minutes.
  • Mixing: With the muffins, our recipe said to mix until the dry ingredients were mixed with the wet, but not until smooth; with the cupcakes, we creamed the butter and mixed longer, until there were no lumps.
  • Flour: There was significantly more flour in the muffin recipe.
  • Sugar: No difference! Both recipes called for the same exact amount of sugar for a batch of 20.
Not a Cupcake.This is a Cupcake.
We then did two taste tests: on the first, we served one from each batch frosted: a frosted muffin (left) and a frosted cupcake (right). And you know what? Nobody could tell which one was the muffin. *Although to clarify, our tasters could tell that each item was different, they couldn't say with confidence which was the muffin and which was the proper cupcake.

On the second taste test, we served both varieties unfrosted. This time, all of our tasters could tell the difference instantly--without that sweet mask of frosting, the difference between texture quickly betrayed the muffin as the more dense and bread-like cupped treat.


Part 3: Our Conclusion


We do believe that there are differences between cupcakes and muffins--to our way of thinking, cupcakes will always be the finer-crumbed, delicate and sweet treat, whereas the muffin is the more dense and hearty option, more likely to have savory flavors or "healthy" stuff added. However, we also believe that the line between the two is blurry in our current age, with more and more sugar and sweet toppings creeping into muffin recipes.

And our preference? Well, duh. Ultimately, it's the cupcake that is first and foremost in our hearts--because for us, cupcakes are always frosted, and that's simply the icing on the cake.


Bookmark and Share

Reader Comments (32)

I think I would understand the difference better if I saw, for instance, a chocolate muffin recipe and a chocolate cupcake recipe side-by-side that yielded the same amount of product.

April 14 | Unregistered CommenterShirese

I had no idea so much thought could be put into the differences, but hey I did type "muffins vs cupcakes" into my google search bar so I guess I asked for it. For the record, I haven't eaten a tasty muffin since I was 13, so my vote goes to a yummy blueberry muffin.

May 17 | Unregistered CommenterPunita

woops, I meant I hadn't had a tasty cupcake in years... not muffin... durr

May 17 | Unregistered CommenterPunita

my poem !! thanks to your site

Cupcakes and Muffins

The light, delicate sponge- craving to indulge
The taste of the frosting swirled above.
Sugar strands sprinkled everywhere,
With the Cupcake flavours on different layers.

Muffins, so large and heavily baked
Having varieties to taste are hard to find.
Excessive sweetened bread bulging over top
With looks that do not attract.

Muffins are not ones to be chosen
So dense with a savoury zest.
The cupcakes will always be exceptional,
Finer-crumbed and a sweet treat for all.

May 27 | Unregistered Commenterkinzxox

I will always love cupcakes more because muffins are just ugly, naked cupcakes!

cupcakes are the best

With the development of tecnology and economy, more and more people tend to pay more attention to their body. They want to have better shape and healthier body. Here, I will introduce a good program to you—p90x price. from America.p90x price is classic training DVD which covers all manner of fitness methods. It include 13 p90x price and beachbody complete training for 90 days. Please image that you will hve your dreamed body and shape in 90 days.There are also many other fasion sports included in p90x. they are waiting for you to find.
How can you learning languages without Rosetta Stone Spanish dvd. Here, I am not point the real stone in British Museum. The real rosetta stone is a stone that has Greek, Egyptian script and the words popular during that time.
If you want to learn another language to improve yourself, you can choose this useful software
Rosetta Stone Spanish dvd to enhance your level of languages.
insanity workout DVD price,insanity workout.com
Turbo Jam Workout DVD,Turbo Jam.com
Turbo Fire Workout DVD,Turbo Fire.com
Body Gospel Workout DVD,Body Gospel.com
Power 90 Workout DVD,Power 90.com
Brazil Butt Lift Workouts DVD
Slim in 6 Workout DVD,Slim in 6.com
Hip Hop Abs Workout DVD,Hip Hop Abs.com
nine eagles helicopters

September 20 | Unregistered Commenterp90x price

An excenlent watch can make you feel good, and that may improve your grade. A successfui businessman must have one kind of

watch to show his special quality. for a lady the watch also can attract many eyes. that is a amazing feeling for owning a

watch. these watches are selected for all kinds of people. you can get your favorite watch freely.
mens watches
breitling navitimer
rolex datejust
breitling crosswind
panerai watches
bvlgari watches
hublot watches
iwc watches
panerai luminor
burberry watches
breitling
panerai watches
hublot watches
omega seamaster
rolex submariner
rolex daytona
watches

September 27 | Unregistered Commentermens watches
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/">Cheap UGGS Boots On Sale</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/">UGGS Boots On Sale</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/">UGGS Boots Sale</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/">UGGS Boots UK</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/">ugg boots on sale</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/">ugg boots</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/">ugg boots uk</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/">cheap ugg boots</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/">cheap ugg boots uk</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">Discount Ugg Boots On Sale</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">Ugg Boots On Sale</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">Ugg Boots Sale</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">Ugg Boots On Sale UK</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">Ugg Boots UK</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/">cheap Ugg Boots UK</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/">discount uggs boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/">cheap ugg boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/">discount uggs boots UK</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/">ugg boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/">uggs boots on sale</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/new-ugg-boots-2010-c-75.html" title="New UGG Boots">New UGG Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-classic-tall-5815-c-65.html" title="Women's Classic Tall 5815">Women's Classic Tall 5815</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-classic-short-5825-c-66.html" title="Women's Classic Short 5825">Women's Classic Short 5825</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-bailey-button-5803-c-67.html" title="Women's Bailey Button 5803">Women's Bailey Button 5803</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-classic-short-5804-c-74.html" title="Women's Classic short 5804">Women's Classic short 5804</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-classic-cardy-5819-c-69.html" title="Women's Classic Cardy 5819">Women's Classic Cardy 5819</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-classic-tall-5812-c-70.html" title="Women's Classic Tall 5812">Women's Classic Tall 5812</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-argyle-knit-ugg-5879-c-71.html" title="Women's Argyle Knit UGG 5879">Women's Argyle Knit UGG 5879</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-romantic-flower-5802-c-73.html" title="Women's Romantic Flower 5802">Women's Romantic Flower 5802</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-classic-mini-5854-c-68.html" title="Women's Classic Mini 5854">Women's Classic Mini 5854</a>
<a href="http://www.realugguk.com/womens-nightfall-5359-c-72.html" title="Women's Nightfall 5359">Women's Nightfall 5359</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/uggs-boots-bailey-button-ugg-boots-c-6_10.html" title="Bailey Button Ugg Boots">Bailey Button Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/uggs-boots-classic-short-ugg-boots-c-6_9.html" title="UGG Boots Classic Short Ugg Boots">Classic Short Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/uggs-boots-classic-tall-ugg-boots-c-6_11.html" title="UGG Boots Classic Tall Ugg Boots">Classic Tall Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/uggs-boots-classic-mini-ugg-boots-c-6_13.html" title="Classic Mini Ugg Boots">Classic Mini Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggdiscountbootsuk.com/uggs-boots-classic-cardy-ugg-boots-c-6_12.html" title="Classic Cardy Ugg Boots">Classic Cardy Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/uggs-boots-bailey-button-ugg-boots-c-6_10.html" title="Bailey Button Ugg Boots">Bailey Button Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/uggs-boots-classic-short-ugg-boots-c-6_9.html" title="Classic Short Ugg Boots">Classic Short Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/uggs-boots-classic-tall-ugg-boots-c-6_11.html" title="Classic Tall Ugg Boots">Classic Tall Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/uggs-boots-classic-mini-ugg-boots-c-6_13.html" title="Classic Mini Ugg Boots">Classic Mini Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.uggscheapestboots.us/uggs-boots-classic-cardy-ugg-boots-c-6_12.html" title="Classic Cardy Ugg Boots">Classic Cardy Ugg Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-classic-tall-boots-c-66.html" title="Ugg Classic Tall Boots">Ugg Classic Tall Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-classic-short-boots-c-67.html" title="Ugg Classic Short Boots">Ugg Classic Short Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-bailey-button-boots-c-75.html" title="Ugg Bailey Button Boots">Ugg Bailey Button Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-mini-boots-c-68.html" title="Ugg Mini Boots">Ugg Mini Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-classic-cardy-boots-c-74.html" title="Ugg Classic Cardy Boots">Ugg Classic Cardy Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-sandals-boots-c-72.html" title="Ugg Sandals Boots">Ugg Sandals Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.discountsuggsboots.com/ugg-slippers-boots-c-73.html" title="Ugg Slippers Boots">Ugg Slippers Boots</a>


<a href="http://www.seo7y.com/" title="南京seo">南京seo</a>
<a href="http://www.gp5u.com/" title="龙港seo">龙港seo</a>
<a href="http://www.gp5u.com/" title="龙港网站制作">龙港网站制作</a>
<a href="http://www.gp5u.com/" title="龙港网络公司">龙港网络公司</a>
<a href="http://www.gp5u.com/" title="龙港外贸公司">龙港外贸公司</a>
December 22 | Unregistered CommenterUgg Boots UK
We have a batch of chocolate muffins going that blurs the line of both of the muffin/cupcake spectrum and sanity itself.

I vote muffins. cupcakes are just small cakes.
February 20 | Unregistered CommenterMike is bored
I am not able to see this website properly on firefox I think there is a problem.
March 29 | Unregistered Commentercheap jordans
I baked a batch of apple cinnamon cupcakes last night for teacher appreciation day. As I was trying one, the thought occured of the difference between cupcakes and muffins. This cupcake was very good without the icing, but with the icing made it a little too sweet. The texture was definitely light and fluffy- as of a cupcake, but without the frosting- wouldn't it just be a muffin? But, I have noticed that some cupcakes NEED the help of icing to make it taste good- like red velvet, you simply can not have it without that wonderful cream cheese frosting! A muffin can be eaten alone- and sometimes that's not good! Because then I find myself actually forming a "muffin top" on my own body! Haha! The icing does play a big part in the difference, as to the time of day you choose to eat it! If you want an excuse for eating cake in the morning....then call it a muffin! Want dessert? You can create a cupcake by simply adding frosting! Either way....it is all soooo good!
May 2 | Unregistered Commenterabfechter
You’ve done a brilliant job in pointing out the potential pitfalls and obstacles involved with this particular subject area, and, most importantly, how they can be overcome. Thanks for a great post and please keep them coming!
June 13 | Unregistered Commenterday skipper
The means of interaction is really the principal inheritor of modernization. And this is what I figured out upon viewing and scanning this site.
Thank you for this info. I've been cooking muffins and cupcakes and I really can't tell the difference until now.
September 1 | Unregistered CommenterThe Daily Recipes
Thanks for sharing so significative article with us. I agree with your idea competely.I am looking forward to another great article from you. And I want to say [url= http://www.cheapmass.net / air jordan fusion shoes ] are so popular, the [url= http://www.cheapmass.net / air jordan fusion shoes ]are fashion and there are so many yong people like them. [url= http://www.cheapmass.net / air jordan fusion shoes ]are hot selling all over the world.
September 15 | Unregistered Commenterair jordan shoes
Hi, the article is so wonderful, I am interested in it. I will pay attention to your articles. And I like [URL=http://www.withgoodsale.com/ cheap clothing] very much, and I have found a
[URL=http://www.withgoodsale.com/ wholesale in china] online, there are [URL=http://www.withgoodsale.com/ cheap shoes] on their website. Especially the [URL=http://www.withgoodsale.com/ wholesale jewelry], they are my favorite!
September 15 | Unregistered Commenterclothing wholesale
It’s worth to read it.Thank you for sharing.canada goose parka will bring you a happy and free life when you are outside for skiing or playing. canada goose are all in good quality, and the price of them is cheap and worthy for you to buy. canada goose jackets sale online in 2011 owns many different designs and materials, you can come and choose. http://www.canadagoose2011parka.org
Nice review. I think I would understand the difference better if I saw, for instance, a chocolate muffin recipe and a chocolate cupcake recipe side-by-side that yielded the same amount of product.
October 10 | Unregistered Commenterapotek dk
would understand <a href="http://www.ugg-outlet2012.com/">ugg outlet</a><br /><a href="http://www.ugg-outlet2012.com/">cheap uggs</a><br /><a href="http://www.ugg-outlet2012.com/">ugg boots sale</a><br />and a chocolate cupcake recipe side-by-side that yielded the same amount of product.
October 20 | Unregistered Commenterugg outlet
Thanks sooo much!! this will help me soo much with my english essay "Muffins VS. Cupcakes", this is the most helpful site i could find! thanks a lot!
November 2 | Unregistered CommenterNicole
ah, yes, the creative outlets of the <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>louis vuitton outlet uk</a> arts and the crafts. Tests and mbt sale examinations fill out the day, as bright little minds gather knowledge form their teacher. But the little hands make the time pass quickly. Contrary to popular belief, the teacher’s work is not through mbt shoes online at the end of the <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>louis vuitton uk outlet</a> school day. Oh, no. There’re many unfinished chores -- blackboards to be cleaned, erasers dusted, and of course the mbt footwear ever-present parent-teacher <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>louis vuitton wholesale uk</a> relationship. He must handle every situation with the utmost dignity. With a complete understanding of mbt chapa shoes his <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>lv outlet uk</a> pupils, the experienced teacher equips himself for the classroom. The students eagerly wholesale mbt shoes return to the classroom. Youthful minds are encouraged to develop their latent talents.So it’s to this great profession <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>discount louis vuitton</a> review and its halls of learning that we dedicate this. When the occasion arises, there’re times when disciplinary actions must be taken mbt m walk. according to the University of Florida's Center for Children.Today, mbt shoes more than ever before, education is playing an important role in the teaching of children. The school has become a vital part of every community, drawing children from every walk of life. The children are eager to take advantage of <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>louis vuitton outlet uk online</a> its opportunities, emerging from their sheltered confines, dipping easily into the habits of the student. They are coming from far and near, struggling towards an education <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>louis vuitton uk</a>, whetting their appetites for knowledge, forming friendships for the future. Childish energy lets nothing stand in its way. In their <a href=http://www.louisvuittonoutletsuk.co.uk/>louis vuitton outlet</a> tiny hands, they hold the future. The person upon whose capable shoulders rests the responsibility for their mbt sneakers education is that unsung hero, the teacher. He must be fair, honest, understanding, and intelligent.
November 4 | Unregistered Commenterlv bags outlet uk

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.
© Cakespy, all rights reserved. Powered by Squarespace.