However, some of our crew is still feeling a bit peaked after the light repast, so we make our way over to the Uptown
location to see the real difference between both locations (read about it here). But then again, is a trip uptown ever really complete without a visit to
? Never have we truly had the feeling of walking into a chocolate chip cookie as we’ve had walking into this place, where the smell envelops you and the cookies ($3.75 ea.) are as big as a baby and just as heavy. Oh yeah, heavy. Walking back toward our hotel via Broadway puts us face to face with
, where we can't help but pick up one of their enormous, Carbohydratey with a Capital C buttermilk biscuits--you know, for later.
Day Four: Is it a surprise that we wake up jonesing? The day starts by picking up a pack of mini black and whites at
Starbucks. Alas, they are not excellent, but we do enjoy the novelty of finding them--awfully cute. Things remain sweet for the day with leftovers from the previous day's jaunts, and when we over to Brooklyn for dinner at carribean-vegetarian-hipster joint
Mighty Diamond in Williamsburg, the sweetest surprise is the rich
vegan chocolate rum cake, which is made in-house. Talk about a diamond in the rough.


Day Five: The day starts with a visit to
Donut Pub on 14th Street, where the donuts are greasy and unapologetically old-school (this is a good thing); defying tradition though, we pick up a black and white cookie, which have clearly just been frosted (this is also a good thing). Worth noting: they also offer "whites" and "blacks" separately, a concept which
seems appealing to those who prefer one flavor or the other, but which in reality is sort of disconcerting. Things stay cozy with hot chocolate from
Max Brenner. Later on, after getting the special "manicure-and-a-drink" for $10 at
Beauty Bar, we walk down to the fairly new
Sugar Sweet Sunshine, recommended by Cake Gumshoe Ian, one of the tasters on day three. Initially we don't know what to make of it: it seems like walking into your hipster friend's living room for cupcakes, but does this mean that you could do it just as well at home? Perhaps, but it's so much funner to let them do it for you: the pistachio cupcake was like sunshine on the cold night, and the
Sexy Red Velvet Cake...well, it was sexy all right. We nightcap with espresso at
Caffe Roma, and though we didn't get any pastries on this visit, we have known and loved their cannoli in the past. Sigh.

Day Six: Starting out early we drop by
Whole Foods Columbus Circle just as they are opening, and are pleasantly surprised by their excellent (made in-house!)
vegan chocolate chip cookies, which are still warm at the time of our visit. The calories burn off nicely zigzagging cross and down to Grand Central, where we pick up goodies at several locations but can't help taking a bite of the
Little Pie and Co. cupcakes immediately. While we don't buy anything at
Balducci's, it is worth mentioning that we stop in and see that they have cupcakes from
Two Little Red Hens and Crumbs. After a day of toil, a few spies still have enough energy to head over to
Billy's Bakery in Chelsea, where the cupcakes are sweet and so is the decor. A crumb is dropped on the sidewalk, and a lengthy conversation ensues about the validity of the "Five Second Rule".

Day Seven: We start the day by taking the grand tour of
Penn Station and then continue on through Chelsea, pausing to taste chocolate mice at
La Bergamote and handmade raspberry marshmallows at
Three Tarts, making our way down to the Village for lovely nonpareils at
Li-Lac and gorgeous pastries at
Lafayette Bakery, where the service can be gruff but the pastry is so, so sweet. We also walk one of our favorites,
Amy's Bread, but hold off for the time being. After a light dinner at
Kate's Joint, we simply can't take another bite, but do enjoy the visuals at
The Grey Dog's Coffee, where the cookies and pies (made in-house) look awfully good, walking back west via St. Mark's Place, we notice that
Whole Earth Bakery (where we love the vegan brownies and vegan truffles) offers
Vegan Trifle--vegans may want to take note!
Day Eight: Resisting sugar overload for just one more day, Head Spy Jessie trains it over to Brooklyn, meeting up with the charming Ann of
Redacted Recipes to ogle the cakes and goodies at
Cheeks in Brooklyn (picked up a triple-chocolate brownie for later) and to have a homey cupcake at
Sweet Farm (sidebar on Sweet Farm: we had visited, but not sampled, this bakery on a previous visit; the cases had not been incredibly enticing at that time. However, things were much better-looking on this visit, so it looks like they have a good rhythm going now). It was the end of the day and the frosting had reached the point of having the ever-so-slightest crunch; while some may not enjoy this, we do. Perfection after a long day of flaneur-esque wandering.

Day Nine: There's only time for a little spying today, with a trip to the airport imminent; luckily, we make good use of our time, imbibing a simply gorgeous coffee at
Joe and managing to fit in a quick visit to the adorable
Thé Adoré on West 13th street and running over to the East Village for pastries to go at
DeRobertis,
Venieros and
Something Sweet before catching the plane home. On the plane, they serve a brownie by
Love and Quiches. We'd call that a sweet ending indeed.
Home again: Finally, on the ninth day, Head Spy Jessie returns home, and the NYC-based Cake Gumshoes get a chance to rest and digest. Would you give these spies some vegetables please?

Places listed in this post: